
If you are on a budget: iPad or Wacom Intuos Pro If you are a more paint/pencil traditional illustrator:iPad Pros If you are a vector illustrator: Wacom Intuos Pro If you don’t have a computer: iPad or iPad Pros Sometimes I use it to sketch ideas but my final illustrations are always done with my Wacom and computer. The iPad for me is more a “fun” thing to have. If I had to choose just one I would pick my Wacom because of my illustration style. I personally have both but use them for different things.
Single purpose: This is purely meant for drawing, unlike the iPad which can be used for games, streaming, etc. You are not drawing directly on the screen. Different Feel: Using a Wacom is more like using an extremely accurate and user-friendly mouse to draw. No Procreate: Cannot use the Procreate app. Not as Portable: The Wacom must be attached to a computer and used on a flat table. If you are reliant on the Pen tool this is a much better option. Vector Illustration: The Wacom is much better using apps like Adobe Photoshop or Adobe Illustrator for vector illustration. Price: Much cheaper than an iPad and the pen is included. Resolution/File size: There are no layer or resolution size limits. I recommend just spending a little bit more on the Pro or saving the money and just going with the regular iPad.
I do not cover the Air as the price point and power seem to sit between the iPad and iPad Pro. *Note: Since this was written Apple has announced the new iPad Air that starts at $599.
Limited Resolution: Since you’re not connected to a computer you are limited in size and scale of your pieces.
Procreate is definitely more for illustration that imitates more traditional paint/pencil styles.
Adobe Illustrator: I am a vector illustrator who relies heavily on Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop which aren’t as good as iPad apps. Price: iPads, especially the Pros are much more expensive, and the Apple Pencils are sold separately adding to the cost. Multi-use: The iPads can also be used for other things outside of drawing, the Pros even make pretty good computer replacements. Portability: The iPad for sure is much easier for on the go drawing and you don’t need to attach it to a computer to use. You can also find classes, tutorials, and special add ons like brushes from teachers all over the internet to make Procreate even better. I have tried the Adobe versions and they just aren’t as user friendly. Procreate: This is considered the best drawing app for iPad.